Bedtime Stories was close behind with a $20.5 million weekend and finally made its $80 million budget back by going to $85 million in total take. Benjamin Button was third with $18.6 million and at $79.2 million so far, still is only just over halfway to making back its lofty $150 million budget.

Valkyrie ($14 million), Yes Man ($13.9 million) and Seven Pounds ($10 million) rounded out the top six as the only movies to go over $10 million on the weekend. While none of these movies are exactly bonfires of the bathroom vanities, the results are mixed as films like Marley and Me overperform, but highly-touted dramas like Tom Cruise’s Valkyrie continue to disappoint.

No new movies debuted over the weekend following New Year’s Eve.