Retconing DOCTOR WHO
Former DOCTOR WHO showrunner Russell T. Davies may not be in charge of all things WHOvian these days, but his upcoming series of SARAH JANE ADVENTURES promises to retcon a key piece of Doctor Who continuity. In the forthcoming storyline, “Death of the Doctor,” Davies will welcome both current Doc Matt Smith, his predecessor David Tennant, and several others in an episode that will reveal that the Doctor can regenerate “far more than 12 times” and that he doesn’t have to remain either white, or male. (And doesn’t need a medical resume to be called The Doctor.)
This retconning of WHO mythology is especially important as current Doctor Who Matt Smith is indicating he doesn’t want his stint to necessarily last as long as Tennant’s. That means the role might have to be recast again in a couple years, triggering the Doctor’s critical twelfth regeneration. Early WHO writers through out the “twelve regenerations” plot device early on, having no idea the show would prove as durable as it has; it was used primarily to make The Master more villainous because he was attempting to live beyond his twelfth regeneration.
Now, apparently, all that continuity is out the window. While I’m sure no one wants whoever follows Smith to be the final incarnation of Doctor Who, nor would anyone want to see BBC toss all the continuity aside and reboot the Doctor from his first regeneration ever, retconning a show in this way is largely frowned upon by science fiction fans.
We’ll have to see how the storyline plays out to determine fan reaction in the coming years.