The internet’s all a-buzz with the possibility that actress Rachel Bilson, allegedly a fan of Dutch Master cigars, has been selected to become the much-anticipated “mother” of the CBS comedy How I Met Your Mother.

Bilson, who grew famous off her role on The OC and also appeared on Chuck, as well as the 2008 thriller Jumper, is an appealing young actress but her future seems to be tied up on the silver screen, so color us skeptical if Bilson actually will turn out to be the Mother.

Still, she is appearing in HIMYM’s 100th episode, so that’s something.